The Best Frakin’ moments of Battlestar Galactica.

Right, so after the whole Plan thing, I decided that the next geeky life thing should focus on BSG. Some BSG fans were not keen on the plan, so let’s look at some awesome moments of the series.
And yes, there are spoilers in here. Some big bad spoilers. So if you haven’t seen it, stay the frak away!
Though I was late to the party, Battlestar Galactica ran for four years highlighting the struggles of the remains of humanity after the Cylons nuked the twelve colonies and ran everyone else out of town. Throughout the show we saw the stresses and intricacies of running from an enemy, lacking resources and manpower and generally having a crappy time.
It’s no surprise that it pushes the envelope and one half of the team that brought back Galactica, Ron Moore, manages to channel hints of his writing on DS9, make it a hell of a lot better and stick the middle finger up to the mistakes he hated about Voyager. What we ended up with was a wonderful series with a lot of character, charm and pain.
I loved it. And while some may not like my pics for the five best moments, these were some of my favourite parts throughout the run.

Apollo finds his balls.
Crossroads Part II (Season 3).
For all the heroics and the angst of Lee Adama in BSG, he was always lesser Adama. He was weak and in a job he didn’t really want to be in, which came up in a nice few lines between him and Tigh after daddy Adama was shot.
Leading up to this moment, Apollo wanted to stand for justice against his own father but couldn’t quite find it within him to get in the game. He assisted Romo Lambkin in defending Baltar when he was on trial for treason, but he wasn’t quite ready to push himself. Not until his daddy gave him a verbal spanking and he handed in his pretty little major pins.
Then we got the speech. For all the great stuff and leadership in BSG, it was obvious there were flaws. We’d already seen the cracks form and Tyrol stand up for the people who were suffering to keep the higher classes alive. Which was a brilliant episode on people being forced to remain in a class system with no escape. But the speech put the knife into Roslin’s way of thinking. In one grand moment of finding his balls, he went against his father, he went against his president and he said all the things that no one else would, or could say.
We make our own laws now; our own justice. And we’ve been pretty creative in finding ways to let people off the hook for everything from theft to murder. And we’ve had to be, because…because we’re not a civilization anymore. We are a gang, and we are on the run, and we have to fight to survive. We have to break rules. We have to bend laws. We have to improvise. But not this time, no. Not this time. Not for Gaius Baltar. No, you…you have to die. You have to die, because, well, because we don’t like you very much. Because you’re arrogant. Because you’re weak. Because you’re a coward, and we, the mob, want to throw you out of the airlock, because you didn’t stand up to the Cylons and get yourself killed in the process. That’s justice now.

Gaeta’s last meal.
Blood on the scales (Season 4)
For all the small character moments throughout the four seasons. I oddly found this one most touching.
At first the two were paired together with Gaeta almost like a protege to the genius and soon enough Gaeta saved Baltar from execution by proving he wasn’t a Cylon sympathizer in the first season. All good, but their relationship took a more interesting turn in season three when the frustrated Gaeta lied on the stand about Baltar on New Caprica, incriminating his friend and former boss from the time they settled on the planet which also included a wonderful moment with Gaeta trying to stab Baltar due to some secret he knew about him.
As Baltar went on his own spiritual path, Gaeta’s life became misreble. He was the loyal officer who’s life turned to shit. And eventually, he cracked, tried to take over the fleet and was executed for his sins.
For all the bad blood between the two, it was touching to see Baltar sit down and share a last meal with him. Gaeta spoke of all the things he wanted to accomplish and Baltar cried over his friends schedule death. It’s not just the connection between them that’s touching, it’s the scene that shows despite his actions Gaeta isn’t a bad guy. He isn’t a big evil villian. He’s a victim of war. He snapped under the pressure and for the guy who’s been the bastard in the two parter, you feel so much empathy for him in that moment.

Adama Falls.
Kobol’s Last Gleaming, Part II (Season 1)
Right from the start, we knew Boomer was a Cylon. She was revealed as such at the end of the miniseries when we saw multiple copies and all of a sudden, her back story of being an orphan made perfect sense. Thoughout the first series, and emphasized in the Plan, we saw her human cover become distressed as she struggled with her own suspicion and discovery that she was a Cylon.
So it was no surprise we’d see her doing some big bad stuff. But the moment itself was fantastic.
She knew there was a mission programmed into her and when she picked up her gun, she knew it was going to be bloody. Baltar discovered she was a Cylon and tried to cover it up, and when he walked in on her looking a little trigger happy, he had a nice chat to her to try and calm her down.
It was a wonderful moment between the two, and one of the few early scenes Baltar spent with a woman without trying to touch her up, but she knew she would do harm and shot herself. It didn’t quite work out fr her as she missed her target, but despite the suicide attempt, Adama still had faith in her and sent her out on a mission to make a Cylon base star go boom.
It was her heroic return when it all happened. Adama welcomed his victirious pilots home, gave them a big warm thank you and when we reached out to shake Boomers hand, the crafty minx pulled out her gun and shot him a good few times, leaving him laying in a pool of blood in CIC.
The Plan gave more insight into this, into how she managed to pull off the misson despite the doubts and how her emotions got the better of her. But the moment it all happened was golden. From camera angles to music, everything was spot on and the story? Well, the fleet chain of command was already in shambles and relying on Adama to lead on. Without him we’re left with the confidential, drunken Tigh and as the shooting brought the series to a close… we were all left wondering if Adama would survive.
The only down side is that they never managed to get a cliffhanger to match this jaw dropper. Even the Cylons descending on New Caprica or Starbucks return didn’t match up.

The Battle of New Caprica.
Exodus, Part II (Season 3)
Quick background. Baltar becomes president, decides to settle on the first next best thing they find to Earth, which he calls New Caprica. A lot of people settle, a few stay behind up in the air. The Cylons pay a visit, force Baltar to cooperate or everyone dies, things go tits up. Those on the planet are under cylon rule, those in the air including the Adama’s with Galactica and Pegasus run for cover.
Tigh leads a resistance cell, doesn’t go well for him, but they manage to get in touch with Galactica who’s coming to rescue them. Oh, and Adma has a horrible mustache.
So there it is. We have the Colonial settlers on the ground, Commander Apollo and the Pegasus is left to guard whats left of the civilian fleet in hiding, and Admiral Adama charged into a suicide mission to get his people off the planet and into safety. And there we have one of the best action shots Galactica has ever been in when it falls from the skies, above the settlement, launches it’s vipers and jumped out of there before it crashes.
The ground troops begin their evacuation under viper cover and the moment moves on. More Cylon base ships move in, Galactica’s wrecked itself in the freefall and can’t hold off any more. Adama thanks his crew and accepts his fate and just at the last possible moment. Boom! Hero ship moment. Apollo arrives with the Pegasus and kicks the shit out of the Cylons. He knows it’s a one way trip for the ship, sacrifices the Pegasus to save his dear old daddy and the day is saved. Mostly.
From the wonderful free fall to the Pegasus save, it’s possibly one of the best sci fi battles I’ve seen. BSG is one of those shows that makes the most out of space battles where others seem ridiculously slow and pointless. DS9’s battles were great, but it was more like a chess game and I’ll bet you a lot of latinum that while you’re thinking about your next move, the Cardassians would have you in checkmate.
Edward Olmos deserves a hell of a lot of credit for bringing that old man to life. His acting along with the writing and the save made the moment all the better. The moments of the battle were a lot more heroic than most writers can pull off.

Jump.
Daybreak, Part II (Season 4.5)
This was it. The grand finale. It was also the most complained about episode ever. Not everyone got what they wanted, they didn’t get their solid, fully explained answers but out of all the open ended questions, the complaints about Starbuck drove me fraking nuts.
Starbuck was told, and believed, she was meant for something special. She committed suicide in order to to it, she found Earth, returned form the dead, found Earth and led the fleet there. Now the death thing can be summed up in Baltars speach. God, which is later said is not it’s name, is a force of nature. So, God can bring back whoever the frak he likes. So that’s fine.
But Earth was wrecked, nuked and uninhabitable. But Starbuck was still discovering her purpose. There wer a few steps to this I won’t recap. But everything she thinks and experiences all culminates on one moment where her purpose in life becomes clear. She’s the saviour.
When all goes tits up, it’s Stabuck’s visions and story that culminated into the fleet jumping from their own personal hell to the safety of Earth where both Cylon and man can live out their lives as one.
And that scene, for me, makes it the number one spot.
Honorable mentions go to Saul Tigh killing his wife on New Caprica as she’s been in league with the Cylons n order to protect her husband, Dualla losing all hope after we learn Earth’s a shit hole and taking her own life in a shocking scene, the final big invasion into Cylon territory and a good few more.
In four seasons and two specials BSG churned out a hell of a lot of good moments. It was a nightmare picking five to add here, but these are my best moments from the show. I’d love to hear yours.
Related posts:
Comments
Comment from theredeemed
Time February 2, 2010 at 1:23 pm
BLOG! The Best Frakin’ moments of Battlestar Galactica. – via @twitoaster http://theredeemed.co.uk/watcher/the-bes...
via Twitoaster
[Reply]
Comment from James Tyler
Time February 2, 2010 at 1:34 pm
Phoenix Rising Discussion:
http://comawhite.co.uk/phoenixrising/forum/on-screen/oops-i-did-it-again-but-with-battlestar-this-time/
[Reply]
Comment from Trekker 47
Time February 2, 2010 at 2:46 pm
The battle of new Caprica was amazing. I was pissed on the first watch that Pegasus went to waste so easily while the bucket was kept as he hero ship. But then the name of the show is Galactica.
What do you mean by the chess game in DS9?
[Reply]
Centurian Reply:
February 2nd, 2010 at 6:49 pm
It was almost Basetar Galactica by the last season!
[Reply]
Comment from Starbuckfanatic
Time February 2, 2010 at 4:08 pm
I would have included the moment Starbucl returned. Or died. Both were great moments. The death scene had a lot more emotion to it and even Tigh shed a tear.
[Reply]
James Tyler Reply:
February 2nd, 2010 at 4:49 pm
The best part of the return for me was the music. It was always obvious they’d never kill her off permanently, so the impact of her return was lessened. The music was spot on though. And despite the obvious revelation of the four hearing the music being Cylons, it had more impact with Tigh’s speech and being unsure what they were going to do next.
But when she died, that was nicely done. With the flashbacks to her mother, her conversation with Leoben (well, not the real one) and the build up to the boom resulting in shouting, tears and drama. All good stuff.
[Reply]
Comment from K
Time February 2, 2010 at 4:38 pm
Im not so keen on the speech. Its spoiled by the episode overall as a Law & Order: Galactica wasnt the best way to close the season. It was saved with Starbucks return and the Cylon reveals which surely merit a better moment than Apollo rambling about justice.
[Reply]
James Tyler Reply:
February 2nd, 2010 at 4:57 pm
I agree in a sense. It wasn’t the best idea to hammer the trial into the finale, but the speech was spot on perfect.
The shades of grey in the lead characters were glaringly obvious and while they thought they were making the right choices, a lot of the time they were very twrong and immoral choices. The hypocrisy of that was pretty much out in the open throughout the trial when we saw the boo-urns bad guy facing an already biased jury for crimes he, mostly, didn’t commit. But Lee was right, others had done bad things and committed crimes but as vital members of the team, they were let off the hook. But nobody liked Baltar. So he must be punished where everyone else was forgiven.
Helo is a great example of this. He put a wrench in Adama’s plan to comit genocide against the Cylons. He betrayed his uniform went against the highest orders and did it anyway because he felt genocide was wrong – and he was very much in the right considering the Cylons were the mustache twirling bad guys of old.
But did Adama care? Not in the slightest. He didn’t even investigate it.
Baltar yielded to the Cylons. If Roslin was in that position she’d fight to the death, resulting in the extermination of mankind. Maybe it’s the more heroic thing to do, but it’s also the most stupid and in a sense… Baltar being a coward saved humanity. He tried to oppose them and he couldn’t. Did he deserve to die for that?
Lee finally grew a set when he got on the stand and pointed out the hypocrisy. And lets face facts, he might have been a leader and a hero… but the man was also a complete pussy. And in this speech he got out of his fathers shadow and what his father wanted for him and made his own choice for a change.
[Reply]
Jon TN Reply:
February 2nd, 2010 at 8:13 pm
I can see your point but Adama not chasing up Helo was less to do with his bad choices and more because he knew he was in the wrong to commit genocide anyway.
I’d say Roslin made more bad choices than Adama. Or maybe I have selective memory
[Reply]
James Tyler Reply:
February 2nd, 2010 at 9:05 pm
It was the first to come to mind, but yeah… Roslin made far more of the wrong choices, such as her stance on the lower class worker I mentione din the original post. I was really rooting for Baftar after her presidency.
Comment from Marty Michaels
Time February 2, 2010 at 5:48 pm
I liked the robot dog. Wait…
[Reply]
James Tyler Reply:
February 2nd, 2010 at 5:57 pm
That was one creepy dog. And that poor monkey.
[Reply]
Jon TN Reply:
February 2nd, 2010 at 8:11 pm
Monkey?
[Reply]
James Tyler Reply:
February 2nd, 2010 at 8:57 pm
The robot dog in the original was inhabited by a monkey. If you’ve never seen it, you will get nightmares.
Comment from Centurian
Time February 2, 2010 at 6:39 pm
The Pegasus joining the fleet was quite a good moment. It didn’t go so well afterwards, in hindsight it’s even better for the viewer, but it was a great moment to finally have some backup.
Another one to add would be the moment Adama found out his best bud was a Cylon and then we get a complete turnaround on their relationship with the old man being the angry drunk and the XO being rational.
Unfinished Business surely should count as well for the big fight with Starbuck and Lee.
For personal moments I’d have put Dualla’s suicide over the Gaeta/Baltar moment.
[Reply]
James Tyler Reply:
February 2nd, 2010 at 7:14 pm
All good moments. The Adama and Tigh scene especially for me.
When it comes to Unfinished Business, the best fight in my view goes to Tyrol versus Adama. Adama giving himself up to have the shit kicked out of him by his deck chief to both prove a point, and allow him to get some payback. His little pep talk afterwards was a nice touch, and something he could have learned from Cain if she wasn’t a mental.
Dualla’s suicide was brilliant. Even though I preferred the quieter scene with Gaeta and Baltar, I remember it being a complete shock the first time I watched it.
[Reply]
Jon TN Reply:
February 2nd, 2010 at 8:11 pm
I was the same with Duala’s suicide. She was a calm constant throughout the show and it was a complete shocker for her to blow her brains out like that.
[Reply]
James Tyler Reply:
February 2nd, 2010 at 8:56 pm
Totally. It added a nice little bit of screwed up to an already dysfunctional set of relationships too.
Comment from Cavil
Time February 13, 2010 at 7:14 pm
A lot of people I’ve talked with it about haven’t been keen on the court sequence which led to Apollo’s speech. I didn’t think it was worthy of the season finale and that Starbucks return was a far better reveal than that or the Cylons.
[Reply]
Comment from Marty
Time February 23, 2010 at 12:54 pm
I’ve net seen enough of nuBSG to know, but does Comander Cain show up? Of course, knowing nuBSG, if he does make an apperance, he’ll probably be a black lesbian alcoholic rather than a gung-ho Battlestar commander, but meh.
[Reply]
James Tyler Reply:
February 23rd, 2010 at 1:19 pm
Cain does indeed show up. Though you’re half right, she is a lesbian. But it’s not an in your face thing, it’s quite subtle and most people missed it.
She’s very much the gung-ho Battlestar Commander (well, Admiral as this time round she has all the power) though, more so than Adama. Where Adama is kind of an old failure who was forced into retirement before the fall, Cain was a more young and dynamic officer who’s expertise took her to the top. She’s all about going out and killing Cylons, she doesn’t give a shit about the fleet, or their mission, she just wants the Cylons to suffer. A lot.
It’s actually one of the more exciting parts of the season – from the moment the Pegasus shows up and gives a glimmer of hope to the story, to the stronger and more powerful Cain taking control, fucking things up for Adama leading to a bit of internal conflict.
And… she’s Ensign fucking Ro! Which was a weird adjustment.
http://en.battlestarwiki.org/wiki/Helena_Cain
[Reply]
Marty Reply:
February 23rd, 2010 at 6:23 pm
Damn. Damn, damn, damn, damn, damn. The emasculation of BSG continues.
[Reply]
James Tyler Reply:
February 23rd, 2010 at 8:12 pm
Dirk, what have I told you about posting here?
In seriousness, I think Cain kills the Benedict theory. She was badass, but she wasn’t a shining beacon of female supremacy. But I don’t want to say too much as I don’t know how much more you plan to watch.
Comment from Marty
Time February 23, 2010 at 10:08 pm
Maybe so, but would it have killed them to have cast a dude? Maybe even THE Dude, Jeff Bridges – considering who played Cain on origBSG, that would have been so right.
[Reply]
James Tyler Reply:
February 23rd, 2010 at 10:18 pm
That makes me wonder what the casting call was – if it was gender specific or if they cast based on auditions. But hey, it was Ensign Ro. All grown up and in charge, shooting whoever pissed her off. I was down with that.
Jeff Bridges should be cast in everything. So I can’t argue there.
[Reply]




James Tyler Reply:
February 2nd, 2010 at 2:52 pm
Galactica was the ship we all loved
I did love that the ship slowly died.
The chess game…
…in Trek it’s all strategy and submarine warfare. There are frantic moments on the bridge, but they’re never really matched in the action – whether they use CGI or models.
While this builds up to tense moments like the scenes in Khan, a lot of the time it’s wasted potential.
The Kelvin sequence in the new Trek film was the first time in a while the action was believable in that franchise. That was a ship firing everything she had, and was getting the crap kicked out of her. Whereas in DS9… there was a lot of stalling. One ship firing on another ship… while both sides just seemed to stand there and watch.
It’s like in action sequences between actors. In Way of the Warrior the Klingons board DS9, but in all the fights we see a Klingon gets hit, then waits for a second blow. The space battles were the same – it was as if everyone was hesitating to fire a button.
BSG, and to some degree SG-1 during the Ori period, were able to convey the more frantic and scary part of warfare which made the interaction in fights far more realistic.
[Reply]